Files
canina/specs/corporate-execution-observability/acceptance-matrix.md
T
2026-10-31 18:45:30 +00:00

6.5 KiB

Bounded acceptance-gap audit

Baseline: develop 69dd6922f6, official Stage run1352. Audit is bounded to existing specs, runtime scripts, corporate service/controller, UI/services and focused/full-suite evidence; not a claim of enterprise acceptance.

Criterion Code/tests Deployment/behavior Verdict / next dependency
Real persisted source provenance corporate research/source tables, validated HTTPS metadata, manual ingest stores fetched bytes and SHA256 Baseline both Stage images independently read as 69dd6922, restart0; source inventory pilot exists, not autonomous business research partial: discovery/synthesis and provider-backed intelligence missing
Monthly research -> persisted roadmap/goals service roadmap requires persisted research with sources; manual CLI manifest Existing integration tests; no demonstrated automatic strategy synthesis partial
Daily NEW article plan separate from refresh UI promises daily new; roadmap counts only; fanout creates source inventories No dated article planning or article executor missing
Needs-based refresh/catalog/wiki/engineering/devops dormant deterministic structural department audits and GET-only plan_day Not clinical enrichment, code execution, or publication; plan is not persisted task fanout partial
Atomic claim/execution/evidence/independent QA service lease fencing, idempotency, TEST, distinct review identity, exact hash verification Existing real disposable DB tests and source-inventory pilot partial: only manual bounded inventory/audits, no business action adapters
Visible instruction/action/result/evidence/QA Task detail shows description and event summaries only; evidence/reviews/effects omitted; TEST absent in frontend status type/filter API detail includes these relations; UI cannot inspect exact receipts missing next slice: read-only persisted execution dossier + TEST status
PMO outcomes/report persisted backend report snapshots, explicit truncation; manual GET-only plan No integrated daily plan/report consumer or report UI partial
Market pagination/filter/search pagination/category UI + backend; no search Not authenticated/mobile accepted in this audit yet partial
Roadmap pagination/filter/search pagination UI, month backend only; no search Not authenticated/mobile accepted yet partial
Tasks pagination/filter/search server pagination, normalized title/code, dept/status/priority Missing TEST option; execution dossier absent partial
SEO under Hermes/mobile existing tracking page and API, independent telemetry limits Requires distinct authenticated mobile review, not proven by compile partial
No fake fallback APIs reject unavailable collections; UI explicit errors; metrics unavailable != zero Preserve; no demo business data added code present, scoped verification required
Test gates baseline full Jest: 2 failures incl wiki expectation and absent isolated DB URLs Repair full gate with fresh private PostgreSQL harness, no live DB reuse partial until repaired run
Public author attribution credentialless genuine authors restored; marker denied all auth paths Baseline API repair confirmed by parent; public attribution UI still unresolved partial; inspect real byline/metadata, never invent credentials/clinical expertise
Autonomous operation runtime explicitly MANUAL_DORMANT, schedules false Must remain cron-disconnected until whole acceptance deliberately not enabled

2026-10-30 next slice (local, not deployed)

  • Persisted monthly planning/API prior Stage acceptance is recorded by release owner (engineering fixtures, not clinical roadmap approval).
  • scripts/corporate_plan_inventory.py now supports explicit prepare roadmap month task, execute child, separate-key qa child evidence, and report child authenticated readback. It copies exact instruction/PLANNED source lineage into a linked RESEARCH prerequisite, verifies selected existing source bytes and hashes, and never submits evidence for the original BLOG_NEW/needs action.
  • Optional claim taskId selects only the exact eligible child, preserves future-plan fences and historical no-selector idempotency hashes; no fallback claim.
  • Real disposable HTTP/PostgreSQL scenario exercises creation/replay, exact execution, self-review denial, independent rejection, corrective execution, independent pass and PMO readback. Original task remains BLOCKED after rejection (TODO on happy path), with no article evidence/review. This is inventory, not synthesis/publication/clinical QA.
  • Independent review found rejection recovery blocked by TODO-only parent guard; fixed for existing linked child snapshot only, with RED/GREEN HTTP regression. New prepare still requires TODO. PMO records observed TODO/BLOCKED, not an invented completion.
  • Local gates: backend 105 suites/950 tests pass (2 existing suites/3 tests skipped), Python 27 tests pass, backend build pass; admin full tests/build pass. Exact logs/source hashes: /opt/data/content-maintenance/corporate-action-evidence-20261030/manifest.json.
  • Remaining: action-specific writers/provider-backed real research, approved business source store/roadmap, Stage acceptance of this slice, integrated monthly/report UI, complete mobile acceptance, controlled activation approval. No schema/approval/publisher/cron/Hermes config/Production changes; MANUAL_DORMANT remains.

Slice selection

First unblock truthful inspection of persisted execution: without exact tool/result/hash and independent QA visible, a higher-level planner would create more uninspectable tasks. Implement read-only dossier, real TEST status/filter, empty and bounded-history disclosures. No schema/business writes, new scheduler, approval modules, Hermes config/restarts, Production or main changes.

Remaining sequence

  1. Accept this dossier and corrected isolated DB gate on exact-SHA Stage.
  2. Research-backed dated daily-new article planning, separate needs-based refresh/catalog/wiki/engineering task lineage, API idempotent persistence (review schema separately if needed).
  3. Implement narrowly allowed action adapters with immutable instruction/action/result/evidence and independent QA; no model-output-is-DONE shortcuts.
  4. Persist PMO outcomes and downstream daily plan; add market/roadmap search/filter/report UI, finish authenticated mobile acceptance and real public author checks.
  5. Only after complete independent acceptance consider explicit activation of the currently dormant/manual runtime; no cron changes in this program slice.